I’ve coached both. Twenty years with elite athletes at Team All-American, followed by the same diagnostic work with executives through Winsignia. What surprised me early on wasn’t how different those two worlds are. It’s how identical the habits of the ones who actually perform turn out to be, once you strip away the uniform.
Here’s the real comparison, not the surface level one about early mornings and cold showers.
Elite Athletes Train the Specific Weakness. Executives Avoid It.
An athlete who’s slow off the line doesn’t spend more time on the drills they’re already good at. A good coach puts them directly into the uncomfortable rep, over and over, until the weakness closes. There’s no ego protection in that room. The weakness gets named and worked, publicly, immediately.
Executives do the opposite by habit, not by character flaw. They spend more time in the parts of the job they’re already strong in, because that’s where the wins feel good and fast. The specific, uncomfortable gap, the hard sales conversation, the underperforming hire, the number that doesn’t add up, gets circled around instead of trained directly. This is the Hard gap in the EFFORT framework, and it’s the single biggest habit difference between the two worlds.
Elite Athletes Measure the Right Number. Executives Measure the Comfortable One.
Athletes at the top level track a small number of metrics that actually predict performance, not the ones that feel good to watch improve. A sprinter isn’t obsessing over total miles run in a week. They’re tracking split times on the specific phase of the race that’s costing them.
Executives, by contrast, often default to tracking activity, hours worked, meetings held, emails sent, because activity is easy to measure and easy to feel proud of. That’s the Smart gap. The habit that separates a performing executive from a busy one is choosing to track the one number tied directly to the actual outcome, even when it’s an uncomfortable number to look at daily.
Elite Athletes Have a Floor. Executives Have a Ceiling.
This is the habit gap that surprises people most. Elite athletes are famous for their peak performances, the record, the highlight, the podium finish. But what actually built that peak is a floor, a minimum standard of training that holds on the days they don’t feel like it, are sore, are dealing with something outside of sport entirely.
Executives tend to build the opposite structure. They have an impressive ceiling, the big presentation, the great quarter, the strong pitch, but no real floor underneath it. When motivation dips, execution drops with it, because there was never a non-negotiable minimum in place to catch the bad week. This is the Consistent pillar, and it’s the habit that compounds the most over a career, for better or worse.
Elite Athletes Get Diagnosed by Someone Else. Executives Diagnose Themselves, Badly.
Every serious athlete has a coach watching from outside, someone whose entire job is to see the gap the athlete can’t see from inside their own effort. That’s not a luxury. It’s a structural habit built into how elite performance actually develops.
Most executives never build that in. They’re the smartest, most self aware person in most rooms they’re in, which paradoxically makes it harder to admit they can’t diagnose their own blind spot the same way an outside eye can. The habit that separates the executives who keep growing from the ones who plateau isn’t intelligence. It’s whether they’ve built in someone whose job is to see what they can’t.
What This Means for How You Build Your Own Habits
The good news buried in this comparison is that none of these habits require an athletic background to build. They require the same honest diagnosis, whether the gap is Hard, Smart, or Consistent, and the discipline to build a floor instead of chasing another ceiling. That diagnostic is the same one I run with every Winsignia client and the same one I bring into a room as a high-performance keynote speaker.
Related Reading
Focus Strategies for Peak Performance
Building High Performance Habits That Actually Stick
Scott H. Fishman is the author of Effort. Scott earned a Bachelor of Education from the University of Miami and later studied Sports Psychology in grad school at the United States Sports Academy. Coach Scott Fishman has earned the top training certifications including CSCS from National Strength and Conditioning Association (NSCA) as well as certification from USA Track and Field (USATF), USA Weightlifting (USAW), USA Basketball (USAB), National Council on Strength and Fitness (NCSF), and more. With 20 years of experience designing high-performance systems for professional athletes, teams and organizations, Scott Fishman is now a keynote speaker. Scott founded Team All-American, AllWorldU, and is the Chairperson of the Board at United Sports Association (U.S.A.). As an athlete, Scott played professional basketball for the Virginia Wolverines (EBA) and North Jersey Pros (EBA). He’s also a marathon runner. Scott is from New York originally and currently resides in the Greater Tampa Bay Area. Scott is the Executive Director of the St. Pete Marathon and the Director of Growth at Winsignia.